Caddy vs Nginx on VPS in 2025: HTTP/3 Performance, TLS Automation, Resource Usage, and Use‑Case Guide

Introduction

Choosing the right web server for your VPS deployment can significantly impact performance, security, and operational overhead. In 2025, two web servers stand out as compelling options: Nginx, the battle-tested veteran with proven scalability, and Caddy, the modern alternative with automatic HTTPS and superior developer experience.

This comprehensive comparison examines both web servers across critical dimensions including HTTP/3 performance, TLS automation capabilities, resource consumption, and real-world use cases. Whether you’re deploying on a Singapore VPS, Sydney VPS, or Amsterdam VPS, understanding these differences will help you make an informed decision for your infrastructure needs.

Prerequisites

Before diving into the comparison, ensure you have:

• A VPS running Ubuntu 22.04 LTS or Ubuntu 24.04 LTS
• Minimum 1GB RAM and 1 vCPU (2GB RAM recommended for performance testing)
• Root or sudo access
• A registered domain name for TLS testing
• Basic understanding of web server concepts
• Terminal access to your server

Nginx: The Proven Powerhouse

Nginx has dominated the web server landscape for over a decade, powering approximately 35% of all websites worldwide. Its event-driven architecture and asynchronous processing make it exceptionally efficient at handling concurrent connections.

Key Strengths

• Battle-tested stability: Proven in high-traffic production environments
• Extensive ecosystem: Thousands of third-party modules and plugins
• Superior caching: Advanced proxy caching and load balancing capabilities
• Low resource footprint: Minimal memory usage even under heavy load
• Flexible configuration: Granular control over every aspect of server behavior

Limitations

• Complex configuration: Steep learning curve for advanced features
• Manual TLS management: Requires external tools like Certbot for certificate automation
• Reload-based updates: Configuration changes require process reload

Caddy: Modern Simplicity with Automatic HTTPS

Caddy represents a paradigm shift in web server design, prioritizing developer experience and automation. Written in Go, it offers automatic HTTPS, HTTP/3 support, and zero-configuration deployments.

Key Strengths

• Automatic HTTPS: Zero-configuration TLS certificate management
• Native HTTP/3: Built-in QUIC protocol support
• Simple configuration: Intuitive Caddyfile syntax
• Dynamic reloading: Configuration updates without service interruption
• Modern protocols: First-class support for HTTP/2 and HTTP/3

Limitations

• Higher resource usage: Go runtime overhead compared to C-based servers
• Smaller ecosystem: Fewer third-party extensions and modules
• Newer technology: Less proven in enterprise environments

Performance Comparison: Benchmarks and Resource Usage

HTTP/3 and QUIC Protocol Performance

HTTP/3 performance varies significantly between the two servers:

Caddy HTTP/3 Performance:

• Native QUIC implementation with excellent performance
• Automatic protocol negotiation
• Built-in 0-RTT resumption support
• Typical latency reduction: 15-30% vs HTTP/2

Nginx HTTP/3 Performance:

• Requires nginx 1.25+ with special compilation flags
• Experimental status in many distributions
• Performance comparable to Caddy when properly configured
• More complex setup and maintenance

Resource Utilization

Based on benchmark testing on VPS instances similar to dedicated vCPU configurations:

Metric	Nginx	Caddy
Memory (idle)	2-8 MB	15-25 MB
Memory (1000 connections)	50-80 MB	80-120 MB
CPU overhead	Very low	Low-medium
Requests/second (static)	25,000-35,000	20,000-28,000

TLS Automation and Certificate Management

Caddy’s Automatic HTTPS

Caddy’s automatic TLS is revolutionary for VPS deployments:

# Simple Caddyfile - HTTPS automatically enabled
example.com {
    root * /var/www/html
    file_server
    encode gzip
}

This configuration automatically:

• Obtains Let’s Encrypt certificates
• Sets up HTTP to HTTPS redirects
• Handles certificate renewal
• Enables modern TLS protocols

Nginx TLS Configuration

Nginx requires manual certificate setup with Certbot:

# Install Certbot
sudo apt update
sudo apt install certbot python3-certbot-nginx

# Obtain certificate
sudo certbot --nginx -d example.com

# Set up auto-renewal
sudo systemctl enable --now snap.certbot.renew.timer

The resulting Nginx configuration requires manual TLS settings:

server {
    listen 443 ssl http2;
    server_name example.com;
    
    ssl_certificate /etc/letsencrypt/live/example.com/fullchain.pem;
    ssl_certificate_key /etc/letsencrypt/live/example.com/privkey.pem;
    ssl_protocols TLSv1.2 TLSv1.3;
    ssl_ciphers ECDHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA512:DHE-RSA-AES256-GCM-SHA512;
    
    # Additional SSL configuration...
}

Installation and Setup Guide

Installing Nginx

# Ubuntu 24.04 installation
sudo apt update
sudo apt install nginx

# Start and enable Nginx
sudo systemctl start nginx
sudo systemctl enable nginx

# Verify installation
nginx -v
sudo systemctl status nginx

Installing Caddy

# Install Caddy on Ubuntu
sudo apt install -y debian-keyring debian-archive-keyring apt-transport-https
curl -1sLf 'https://dl.cloudsmith.io/public/caddy/stable/gpg.key' | sudo gpg --dearmor -o /usr/share/keyrings/caddy-stable-archive-keyring.gpg
curl -1sLf 'https://dl.cloudsmith.io/public/caddy/stable/debian.deb.txt' | sudo tee /etc/apt/sources.list.d/caddy-stable.list
sudo apt update
sudo apt install caddy

# Verify installation
caddy version
sudo systemctl status caddy

Use Case Recommendations

Choose Nginx When:

• High-traffic websites: Need maximum performance and minimal resource usage
• Complex routing: Require advanced load balancing or proxy capabilities
• Enterprise environments: Need proven stability and extensive third-party integrations
• Microservices: Acting as an API gateway or reverse proxy
• Resource-constrained VPS: Operating on instances with limited RAM

Choose Caddy When:

• Rapid deployment: Need quick, secure deployment with minimal configuration
• Development environments: Want automatic HTTPS for testing and staging
• Modern protocols: Prioritize HTTP/3 and QUIC performance
• Small to medium websites: Don’t require extensive customization
• DevOps automation: Benefit from zero-configuration deployments

Best Practices and Security Considerations

Nginx Optimization

• Worker processes: Set to match CPU cores for dedicated vCPU instances
• Connection limits: Tune worker_connections based on available RAM
• Caching: Implement FastCGI or proxy caching for dynamic content
• Rate limiting: Use limit_req modules for DDoS protection

Caddy Optimization

• Resource limits: Monitor memory usage on smaller VPS instances
• Certificate storage: Use persistent storage for certificate data
• Logging configuration: Implement structured logging for better monitoring
• Security headers: Configure appropriate security headers in the Caddyfile

Security Warning: Always test configuration changes in a staging environment before applying to production servers. Incorrect web server configuration can expose sensitive data or create security vulnerabilities.

Conclusion

The choice between Caddy and Nginx in 2025 depends largely on your specific requirements and operational priorities. Nginx remains the champion for high-performance, resource-efficient deployments requiring extensive customization. Its proven track record and vast ecosystem make it ideal for enterprise environments and resource-constrained VPS instances.

Caddy excels in scenarios prioritizing developer experience, automatic security, and modern protocol support. Its zero-configuration approach and built-in HTTPS automation make it perfect for rapid deployments and development environments.

For VPS deployments on modern infrastructure like Onidel’s high-performance EPYC Milan processors, both servers will deliver excellent results. Consider Nginx for maximum efficiency on shared resources, or Caddy for simplified operations and cutting-edge protocol support.

Ready to deploy your chosen web server? Explore our VPS offerings across multiple regions, featuring NVMe storage, automatic backups, and advanced networking capabilities to support your next project.